Strategy & Leadership

Two CFOs Took the CEO Chair in a Week. Internal CFO Promotions Hit a Record Low.

Boards are leaning on finance chiefs to run the whole company, and turnover in the CFO seat is at an eight-year high. The bench behind those finance chiefs is getting thinner just as it is needed most.

November 18, 2026 · Strategy & Leadership
An empty modern boardroom with a long wooden conference table, rows of black office chairs, wood-clad columns and floor-to-ceiling windows

Key Takeaways

  • In the space of a week, Nvidia named CFO Colette Kress interim CEO and Home Depot promoted CFO Richard McPhail to CEO, while JPMorgan Chase named 43-year-old Bregje de Best as its next CFO.
  • Russell Reynolds Associates puts global public company CFO turnover at 15% through Q3 2026, the highest in eight years, and at 19% in the S&P 500.
  • Internal candidates filled 53% of CFO appointments, down from 56% a year earlier and the lowest Q1 to Q3 share in the index's eight-year history.
  • Crist Kolder Associates found 10.26% of CEOs at Fortune 500 and S&P 500 companies in 2025 came directly from the CFO role, up from 7.1% in 2024, and every one of those promotions was internal.

When a board needs someone to hold the company steady, it increasingly looks across the table at the finance chief. Two of the largest companies in America did exactly that in the past week. Each move also left a finance function that had to answer the same question at once: who runs it now? New turnover data suggests more companies are struggling to answer that from inside, at the moment the CFO seat is changing hands faster than it has in eight years.

A Week of Finance Chiefs Moving Up

On November 12, Nvidia said Jensen Huang had resigned as CEO, president and director, effective immediately, and named long-time CFO Colette Kress interim CEO while the board searches for a permanent successor. Kress, 59, joined Nvidia in 2013 and keeps her roles as executive vice president and CFO. Shares fell as much as 14% before recovering some losses. Morningstar senior equity analyst Brian Colello called Kress "a reasonable interim CEO candidate who could provide continuity during a leadership transition."

Five days later, Home Depot said CFO Richard McPhail will become CEO on November 23, succeeding Ted Decker, who is stepping down after a medical leave. McPhail has been CFO since September 2019 and has spent nearly 22 years at the company. Unlike Nvidia, Home Depot named a finance successor at the same time: company veteran Jordan Broggi, 43, becomes CFO. JPMorgan analysts said "Richard's appointment stays true to the importance of having a culture-carrier leader."

The same day, JPMorgan Chase named Bregje de Best as its next CFO, succeeding Jeremy Barnum after first-quarter earnings on April 13. De Best, 43, is CFO of the commercial and investment bank and has spent her entire 20-year career at JPMorgan. Barnum becomes a vice chairman and stays through early 2028. TD Cowen analyst Scott Siefers called the news a surprise but said the transition "seems orderly."

The Pipeline to the Top Is Widening. The One Into Finance Is Not.

The CFO-to-CEO route is no longer unusual. Crist Kolder Associates' 2025 Volatility report found that 10.26% of CEOs at Fortune 500 and S&P 500 companies came directly from the CFO role in 2025, up from 7.1% in 2024 and the highest level in a decade. All of the observed CFO-to-CEO promotions were internal. In Europe, Spencer Stuart data reported by Fortune shows 21% of CEO appointments at the largest listed companies last year were former CFOs, second only to divisional chiefs.

Each of those promotions opens a finance vacancy, and the CFO seat is already turning over quickly. Russell Reynolds Associates' CFO Turnover Index, as reported by CFO Brew, puts global public company CFO turnover at 15% through the third quarter, its highest mark in eight years, and 19% in the S&P 500. Retirements and moves to board roles made up 61% of departures, up from 57% in 2025. RRA's Jenna Fisher described many leaving CFOs as choosing to "go out on a high note, and pass the torch."

The torch is increasingly passed outside. Internal candidates filled 53% of CFO appointments this year, down from 56% and the lowest share for the first three quarters in the index's eight-year history. The bench is narrowing in another way too: women accounted for 22.9% of CFOs appointed globally in Q3, down from 25% a year earlier. Put together, finance leaders are being pulled upward and out at a high rate, and fewer companies are finding the replacement already on the team.

What the Next CFO Has to Be Able to Do

The skills that make CFOs credible CEO candidates are not the ones finance teams have traditionally trained for. RRA's Jim Lawson told CFO Brew that investor communication has become "just paramount" for public company CFOs. Leaders interviewed by Fortune describe the same shift. "The number crunching, facts, and research, is all going to be done by models," said Mark Thumser, chief financial and strategy officer for the Americas at MUFG. Booking.com CFO Uvashni Raman put it more bluntly: "You will not be as effective a leader if you just stay within finance."

There is a caution in the data as well. Spencer Stuart's analysis of 1,300 CEOs, cited by Fortune, found former CFOs were the least likely to rank in the top quartile for CEO performance. A finance chief's promotion is not proof that the finance function produced a complete leader. It is proof that boards value the continuity, credibility with investors and command of the numbers that a sitting CFO brings, and that the company now needs the next one. Home Depot and JPMorgan both named insiders who had run large finance organizations of their own. That is what a bench looks like when it exists.

The Playbook: Build the Bench Before the Board Calls

Share

More in Strategy & Leadership

All Resources →
✕